Home  About  Words  Archive  Photography  Links  Surf and Weather 
« «
 » »

Free Tigger!

For coming to class at a Napa middle school wearing hosiery that portrayed the Winnie the Pooh character — in violation of the school’s solid-colors-only, no-pictures, no-logos dress code — the seventh-grader landed in the principal’s office, and then in a detention program called Students With Attitude Problems.

Now Redwood Middle School and the Napa Valley Unified School District, which approved the code, have landed in court.

The school’s “unconstitutionally vague, overbroad and restrictive uniform dress code policy” flouts state law, violates freedom of expression, and wastes teachers’ and students’ time and attention that would be better spent on education, the American Civil Liberties Union said in a suit filed Monday on behalf of six students and their parents.

Actually, the banning of Tigger-wear is probably among the least offensive results of their dress code, despite local affection at Howling Point for Tigger and other tigers.  According to the S.F. Gate article, one student was cited for wearing a shirt with the words “Jesus Freak” and another for wearing a pink Breast Cancer Awareness Ribbon.   Even if you accept that schools should be teaching appropriate expression by banning poor choices (like gang colors), there’s no way that banning all expression is an appropriate solution.

Chuck posted this on Wednesday, March 21, 2007 at  7:24 am.   6 comments have been made. Join them. 

6 Responses to “Free Tigger!”

  1. Mike says:

    They’re trying to do a dress code like that here in Indianapolis public schools. In theory I don’t have a problem with it, but if it’s as restrictive as the above school, enforcement there’s no way it’ll fly.

  2. Randy says:

    Gray polo shirts, gray slacks/skirts, navy blue sweater, tennis shoes.

    Buy 5 sets at the beginning of the year and you are set.

    R

  3. Chuck says:

    Set, but boring, and having utterly failed in teaching the children how to properly express themselves.

    Don’t forget that the polo shirts can’t be Polo™ shirts without violating the policy.

  4. Randy says:

    According to Lands End…polo is more a style than a brand name.

  5. giga says:

    Not sure how I feel on this one. At first I’m thinking “uniformity in school is good, and them’s the rules, so deal.” But, there are other issues, such as whether the school is billed as a “uniform school,” whether there is open enrollment (choice between schools), etc.

    We had a no-tshirts-with-writing dress code. Button downs were fine. By high school, we were all pushing limits, and the administration let us, to an extent. Skorts were coming into fashion, and girls were wearing shorts, as well, which were against the dress code. Since the school was also not air conditioned, and would frequently be 90 degrees in spring and fall, the boys were getting ticked off. I started a petition which got the signatures of every male in the school, and the principal laughed it off, and said “not in my school.” The school board overruled him at the next meeting and changed the code.

    If they want to wear Tigger, let them petition to wear Tigger… why get costly lawyers involved?

  6. giga says:

    I should say “no offense to costly lawyers who need to make a living.”

Leave a Reply

Bookmark and Share

This Post is Tagged:

Recent Comments

Chuck wrote "Lots of brains for the zombies to snack on at the Con."

TJ wrote "yes, you have neglected us. and we don’t appreciate you’re running around enjoying yourself like this (smile). an..."

spinnerdude wrote "He actually wants to stay married to me!"

Chuck wrote "Tried twice and never put the words together to describe the 2010 Comic-Con in a post. Interested in our experience? Go to..."

Chuck wrote "The fund raiser went great. For the record, I wore a t-shirt and shorts."

TGIF Photos

Saturday morning, December 22, 2007 (Winter Solstice): Taken on the north side of the Crystal Pier in Pacific Beach.

Recent Tweets

Chuck...

Recent Beachlaw Posts

Cliff Jumping - Posted 7 weeks ago

Swimming Without A Lifeguard - Posted 2 months ago

Technical Post - Posted 2 months ago

Search The Blog

Top 30 Tags

Blogs Being Stalked

17th Man

CriticalMAS

Endless Banter

Gold Medal Mel

Jimbo

Jocko Blood & Shaving Cream

Legal Moose

Looka!

Mikerzz

Scott Barnes

Spinnerdude

Sqooped


More Personal Sites

Anachronistic Behr

Bedtime Stories

Cheap Blue Guitar

Defective Yeti

Deus Ex Malcontent

Dooce

Jason P. DeFillippo

Joe and Leah Reboot

Nerdist

Plastic Crack

Sean Bonner

Sissyfish

Sturtle

What Some Would Call Lies

Zefrank


Assorted Linkage

404 Research Lab

BadJocks

CIA World Factbook

California Digital Library

David Friedman Photography

Internet Movie Data Base

Legal Marketing

Libertarian Party

MavSurfer

Overlawyered

Photography | Law

PostSecret

San Francisco Gate

Shorpy

Surfrider Foundation


Buttons and Badges



Subscribe

White Knot
06 Friday